+1-201-470-4181
·
office@Pagliaralawgroup.com
·
Open: 24/7
Free case consultation
HABLAMOS ESPAÑOL

Arrested During a Medical Emergency in New Jersey? What You Need to Know

Pagliara Law Group > Blog > Arrested During a Medical Emergency in New Jersey? What You Need to Know

By Nicholas A. Pagliara, Esq., Pagliara Law Group, P.A.

On Monday, November 16, 2026, a three judge appellate panel in Trenton heard the State of New Jersey’s challenge to an $11.3 million jury verdict in a case that began on Route 78 in 2017. According to the New Jersey Monitor, a Jersey City woman struck a guardrail on her way to work. A rookie New Jersey State Trooper who responded concluded she was drunk. Her lawyer says dashcam video shows her asking for help and saying she thought she was having a heart attack, and that she showed classic stroke signs, including a drooping face, trouble speaking and loss of control of her right arm and leg.

Instead of a hospital about 10 minutes away, she was taken to the Somerville barracks and shackled to a bench in a holding cell, and medical care was delayed for hours. Her lawyer says the delay led to a brain bleed that left her unable to communicate and in need of lifelong care. A jury in January 2025 found that the trooper did not cause the stroke but attributed 60 percent of the woman’s injury to the trooper’s conduct. The State now asks the court to grant the trooper immunity, order a new trial, or cut the damages. No ruling has been issued, and our thoughts are with the woman and her family as the case continues.

This case raises a question many New Jersey families never expect to face: what happens when police mistake a medical emergency for a crime?

When Police Ignore a Medical Emergency, the Law Can Hold Them Accountable

Strokes, diabetic emergencies, seizures and head injuries can look like intoxication. Slurred speech, confusion and unsteady walking are warning signs officers are trained to recognize. When a person is in police custody, they cannot get themselves to a doctor, so the law places a duty on officers to provide or summon medical care for serious needs.

Under the federal civil rights law known as Section 1983, and under its state counterpart, the New Jersey Civil Rights Act, a person can sue when a government official violates their constitutional rights. Ignoring an obvious and serious medical need of someone in custody, often called “deliberate indifference,” can be such a violation. Separate negligence claims may also arise when officers fail to follow their own training.

Immunity Is the Main Battleground

As this appeal shows, the biggest fight in many police cases is immunity. Officers often argue they acted reasonably and in good faith, and that the law protects them from personal liability. Under both federal qualified immunity and the New Jersey Tort Claims Act, that defense can be strong. But immunity is not automatic. Where the evidence shows an officer ignored obvious symptoms, disregarded training, or acted with deliberate indifference, courts and juries can and do reject it.

Both the federal and New Jersey civil rights laws allow a winning plaintiff to recover reasonable attorney fees from the government defendant. This fee shifting is meant to make sure people with valid claims can find lawyers willing to take on powerful public agencies.

Deadlines and Evidence Matter

When a claim involves a state agency, county, town or police department, New Jersey generally requires a written notice of tort claim within 90 days of the incident for negligence and similar state law claims. Missing that deadline can bar recovery on those claims, and late notice is allowed only in limited circumstances with court permission. Civil rights claims under Section 1983 and the New Jersey Civil Rights Act generally carry a two year statute of limitations. Special rules can extend deadlines for minors, but you should never assume a deadline has been extended.

Evidence is often decisive. In this case, dashcam footage reportedly captured the driver asking for help. Body camera and dashcam video, dispatch recordings, holding cell logs, use of force reports and training records can show what officers saw and when. Some of these records may be requested under the Open Public Records Act (OPRA), and others can be obtained in litigation, but recordings may be overwritten if no one asks to preserve them.

What to Do If Police Ignored Your Medical Emergency

  1. Get medical care right away and tell the doctors exactly what happened, including how long you waited for treatment.
  2. Write down everything you remember: times, locations, officer names, badge numbers and patrol car numbers.
  3. Collect the names and phone numbers of any witnesses, including family members who arrived later.
  4. Keep all paperwork, including summonses, hospital records, discharge papers and bills.
  5. Do not post about the incident on social media or discuss it with insurance adjusters or the police department.
  6. Contact a civil rights lawyer quickly so a 90 day tort claim notice can be filed and video can be preserved.
  7. Ask your lawyer about requesting body camera and dashcam footage and other records through OPRA and litigation.

Talk to Pagliara Law Group

If you or a loved one was mistreated, denied medical care or wrongly arrested by police in New Jersey, Pagliara Law Group, P.A. can review your case at no cost. We handle civil rights and personal injury cases on a contingency fee basis, which means there is no attorney fee unless we recover for you. Hablamos español.

Call (201) 470 4181 or email Office@pagliaralawgroup.com for a free consultation.

Pagliara Law Group, P.A., 500 Paterson Plank Rd., Union City, NJ 07087

Attorney Advertising. This article provides general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. News facts are as reported as of November 17, 2026, and the case remains pending on appeal; facts may change as proceedings continue.

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Recent Articles

Electric scooter crash in New Jersey, Pagliara Law Group, P.A.
Injured in an Electric Scooter Crash in New Jersey? What Riders and Parents Need to Know
November 16, 2026
Lawsuit Filed against County of Hudson and HCSO for Wrongful Arrest Due to Mistaken Identity on Another Person’s Warrant
February 27, 2026
Lawsuit Filed against The Shannon Bar in Hoboken for Security/Bouncer Assaulting a Patron outside.
November 22, 2025

Archives

FREE CONSULTATION